Why do some people love cliff diving and others get queasy at just the thought of peering over the edge of a cliff?
Clearly risk is personal. What feels risky to me may not feel risky to you, and vice versa.
For that reason, any good financial plan must begin with understanding the unique way risk impacts your personal financial plan. Financial advisors call this your “risk profile.”
What is a Risk Profile?
To begin, a risk profile is not the same thing as a risk assessment, which is a tool you may have encountered before, either online or with an advisor.
A risk assessment attempts to pin a number to how comfortable you are with risk. Such an assessment might ask questions like, “Would you rather have a guaranteed gain of $1,000 or a 50% chance at $5,000?”
A risk profile more holistically informs how much investment risk you can and should take on in order to accomplish your goals, which it does by answering three questions.
The 3 Areas a Risk Profile Measures
1. Your Plan’s Risk Capacity
Your risk capacity is how much risk your financial plan can withstand, i.e., the impact a market downturn would have on your portfolio.
When determining risk capacity, we look at several factors, including:
- Time horizon – How many years until you retire? The longer the horizon, the more time your portfolio will have to recover from a downturn.
- Income sources – Stable external income sources such as a paycheck serve as a safety net and can increase your risk capacity.
- Assets – The amount of your savings is proportional to how much market volatility you can sustain.
- Liquidity needs – If you need to withdraw money on an ongoing basis, then your risk capacity will be lower.
The combination of these factors and others help us determine how high we can and should turn the “risk” knob on your plan.
2. How Much Risk Your Plan Requires
Risk is directly tied to returns when investing. The higher the risk, the higher the potential returns, and vice versa. If your financial plan requires your portfolio to grow more rapidly, you will need to take on more risk.
Before you can determine how much risk your plan requires, you must set goals first. This goes back to the idea of establishing what you want out of retirement.
In order to understand how much risk your plan requires, you need to know your plan. In order to know your plan, you need to set goals. In order to set goals, you need to know what you want out of retirement.
3. Your Risk Preference
Last but not least, we need to understand how a market downturn would impact you on an emotional level. Risk is an inherently uncomfortable thing, no matter how high your risk preference. The goal of matching your risk preference to your portfolio is not to eliminate risk, but to invest in a way that puts you on track to meet your goals while still allowing you to sleep at night.
If a market downturn would make it impossible for you to sleep, then the risk level of your portfolio is higher than your risk preference.
This information is foundational for the rest of your profile because it determines whether you will be able to follow the plan. If my investment plan requires me to invest more aggressively than I am comfortable with, then a market downturn may scare me into selling, rendering my plan useless. Any plan you can’t stick to is more of a wish list than a plan, and a wish list won’t do us much good when it comes to planning for retirement.
Risk preference is unique in that it is the most malleable determining factor of your risk profile. It can change from day to day based on what’s going on in the news, how you’re feeling, or other variables in your life. Whereas the first two factors are largely objective, risk preference is totally subjective.
Your relationship with risk will evolve throughout your life. For instance, your risk preference in retirement is often lower than the rest of your life. When the paychecks stop and you’re living off of your portfolio alone, losses tend to feel different. Naturally, most people are more loss averse at this point in life, regardless of how risk tolerant they may have been in their earlier years.
This is where working with an advisor who understands you can make a big difference. In moments of fear, your advisor can help you remember why you are taking the risk in the first place. In moments of overconfidence, your advisor can help you avoid taking more risk than is needed.
How Retirement Changes Your Relationship with Risk
Our relationship with risk evolves as we grow older. Take market downturns, for example.
Market ups and downs are a normal part of the investor experience. When investing, we all want to buy low and sell high. When retirement is still decades away, a market downturn is an opportunity – namely to buy low. But when you’re in retirement, a downturn is a threat, one that could permanently shrink your portfolio.
Sequence of returns risk is the idea that poor market returns early in retirement, when people typically begin selling shares so they can withdraw money to live on, can have an outsized impact on your ability to fund your retirement. Experts often refer to the last five years before you retire and the first five years after as the “fragile decade.” These years are fragile because at this time, market swings could have a greater impact on your ability to fund retirement if you don’t have guardrails in place.
The sequence of returns doesn’t matter as much when you are still working, because you are not withdrawing from your portfolio, you are still accumulating wealth. But once you start withdrawing, the size of the returns begins to matter quite a bit.
Your Risk Profile Measures How You Will React in Theory – Retirement is the Real Test
A risk profile is a valuable tool for helping you prepare for retirement, but it is just that: a tool. The real test comes when you are actually in retirement, when you stop planning in theory and start living out your plan.
If you need help building a plan that matches your risk profile, click here to schedule a consultation with us.



